How safe is the Hudson River for swimming after being a dumping site for sewage and industrial waste for so many years?

Lewis Pugh swimming the length of the Hudson River in 2023, shown passing by the decommissioned Indian Point Plant south of Peekskill, NY.
FBW | October 6, 2025
Hundreds of swimmers dove into the Chicago River on September 22 for a series of distance races. This was the first time in 98 years that a swim event took place in the Chicago River.
The Chicago River, like so many waterways around the world, was formerly used as a dumping site for sewage and industrial waste. Chicago’s massive slaughterhouses and meatpacking plants dumped animal wastes into the river. The City’s combined stormwater and sewer system was the source of fecal coliform bacteria. The Chicago River threatened the city’s water source as it flowed into Lake Michigan.
Given the river’s fetid history, the news of the swim came as a shock to many. Was this a safe, healthy activity in which to participate? The answer appears to be yes. Advanced water quality tests were conducted beginning 19 days before the event to ensure that human exposure was safe.
The Chicago River Swim was inspired by a similar charity event, a swim in the canals of Amsterdam, an annual event that started in 2011. The 2024 Olympics in Paris held triathlon and marathon swimming events in the River Seine, which had been off limits for swimming since 1923 due to severe contamination. Paris now allows swimming in three supervised sites in July and August featuring lifeguards, safety buoys and daily water quality checks.
The federal Clean Water Act of 1972 was a turning point for the health of rivers in the US. In the years since, federal, state and local regulations have put an end to many polluting practices. The Riverkeeper movement began in the 1980s and soon spread across the U.S., closely monitoring the health of rivers and identifying sources of pollution.
The Riverkeeper movement started with the Hudson River Fishermen’s Association in 1966. Like other rivers around the world, the Hudson River suffered from more than a century of abuse. Today, however, water quality has improved considerably.
In 2023, during the months of August and September, Lewis Pugh, a British endurance athlete, swam the 315-mile length of the Hudson River, starting at its source, Lake Tear of the Clouds in the Adirondack Mountains and finishing at Battery Park City at the south end of Manhattan. Pugh stated at the time, “I did it to highlight the importance of clean rivers.”
Several swims now take place around Manhattan every year. The 20 Bridges Swim Around Manhattan is a 28.5-mile marathon swim. Solo swims follow a similar route with personal support crews. Urban Swim, a New York City-based organization, has promoted shorter distance events such as PRIDE Swim Manhattan, the Statue of Liberty Swim and the Liberty to Freedom Swim.
As more people participate in kayaking, stand-up paddle boarding and swimming, there is also an increased interest in further improvements to water quality in our rivers. Water testing conducted in the Hudson River and other waterways within the New York and New Jersey Harbor Estuary began on a regular basis in 2012. Over the years, the number of test sites and sampling has grown, with samples taken on a weekly basis over the 20 weeks from May through September.
The data is reported on the Billion Oyster Project’s website. One thing is clear, it is not safe to swim in the Harbor Estuary rivers when it rains or the day after a rain. During dry weather, tests often showed water to be safe for swimming but not always. A summary of data from 2024 showed that 51% of the tests showed that water quality was unsafe for swimming and 31% of the tests found safe conditions for swimming.
Like Chicago and so many other waterfront cities, the aging sewer infrastructure of Hoboken and New York City combine sewage and stormwater into a one pipe system. During rain events, the sewerage treatment plants are overwhelmed, causing sewage to flow into the Hudson River and other waterways. This is the main source of fecal coliform bacteria that can make waterways unsafe for swimming.
Since 2014, Noelle Thurlow of Resilience Adventures in Hoboken has been testing the water in the Hudson River at four sites: the Weehawken Cove, Pier 13, the Hoboken Cove and Sinatra Park. The results of these tests are part of the data shown on the Billion Oyster website. After the rain for three weeks last May, it consistently showed water quality at unsafe levels for swimming. The Hoboken data varied depending on the location, with the best results showing up for the Weehawken Cove and Pier 13 with safe swimming levels indicated for 50% and 45% of the tests, respectively.
The North Hudson Sewerage Authority that serves Hoboken, Weehawken, West New York and Union City has a long-range plan for upgrading its treatment facilities and sewer lines. The Hudson River Rebuild by Design project is investing $100s of millions in flood mitigation measures focused primarily in Hoboken, that store and delay the release of stormwater into the sewer system. An analysis of Hoboken’s Hudson River water quality data could determine if these improvements result in improved water quality.
An international, nonprofit organization, Swimmable Cities, has approached FBW to join this movement. Current data can be further analyzed to understand when and where river quality is safe for swimming. Additional testing locations at various distances from the shoreline could yield valuable data.
Floating pools provide an alternative option. FBW’s 1990 Plan for the Hoboken Waterfront included a floating pool at the end of a pier. The Neptune Foundation has promoted this idea and built a pool on a retrofitted barge that is now docked at Barretto Point Park in the Bronx, providing swimming opportunities for an underserved population. +Pool is currently building a structure that will be located at Pier 35 in the East River and will filter the river’s waters for safe swimming. The cost of building this pool, however, has reached tens of millions of dollars, far exceeding original estimates.
FBW will continue to monitor water quality at the Hoboken shoreline and further analyze the data to understand what makes for safer swimming conditions. FBW will work with Resilience Adventures, the Hoboken Cove Community Boathouse and other organizations to advocate for practices that further improve water quality in Hudson River.
Related Links
Is a floating swimming pool in Hoboken’s future?
The Hudson River fishermen and the boat that began the Riverkeeper movement
Noelle Thurlow says Hoboken Cove is prime candidate for habitat restoration
Noelle Thurlow explains why the Hoboken Cove is so unique
Photos from City of Water Day 2025 in Hoboken
A plan to remove a colony of nesting terns on a Hoboken pier goes awry
